“Learning ‘infantilised’ by relying on Internet”?

It seems home educating families are not the only ones worried by a fast track attitude to acquiring knowledge for the sake of an education.

In this article ‘Learning ‘infantilised’ by relying on Internet’ (here) Helen Fraser talks about the dangers to their learning of children getting quick-fix answers off the Internet rather than being educated to a deeper understanding.

I want to bring back thinking – and I think a lot of what happens on the internet is antipathetic to thinking and suggests there is no alternative view,” says Ms Fraser… “Learning should be about engaging with ideas, rather than “regurgitating facts”, she says.

I think she’s probably summed up what’s wrong with our system of education overall in that statement and why so many of us are choosing the home school route as an alternative. Because many parents are realising that education is so much more about a process of personal development than it is about finding stuff out and being able to replicate it.

Sadly that’s all it’s become to many children who think education is about having the answers and who want to get them as quickly and painlessly as possible, and to many parents who just want their kids to get the grades. Probably because they’ve bought the propaganda that you won’t have a life if you don’t!

There’s no doubt that the Internet has brought a whole new aspect to education in that it makes knowledge available to all (as long as you have access, of course). And is a wonderful tool.

But with this knowledge accessibility, which we once relied on the fact-superior teachers for as they were the only access to it when most families didn’t even have books or the skill to read them, perhaps now is the time to reassess our view of what kids need schools and teachers for.

Perhaps it’s time for schools to be less about academic cramming and more about developing our young people to think for themselves; think about their lives beyond schools and grade getting and what they want to do with them, rather than just getting their education over with.

Everything we did as home educators was about the development of the person; personally. It was about building skills for a productive, fulfilling and happy life. And the kids understood that. It was never for the good of an institution, for our adult satisfaction, or for the acquisition of meaningless facts and grades – although they did become a meaningful part of the process as they got older.

But I do wonder how many school children honestly feel their education is really, meaningfully, for them as they search the Internet desperately looking for ‘right’ answers to get the homework done, rather than engaging with ideas, which is really what makes them educated!

7 thoughts on ““Learning ‘infantilised’ by relying on Internet”?

  1. I know what you mean. Our home education slant has always been to question what is said. I know it has worked as Will is constantly questioning what politicians and journalists say. We use the internet but we also use books. We read them to each other and discuss the writer’s point of view. Thinking for yourself is one of the most important part of an education, wherever we get it from. Great post.

  2. I like your take on this issue. I agree that it’s certainly no worse to rely on the Internet than on the few , carefully groomed teachers one has through school, in fact, over 90% of the research for my blog is done online.
    Another homeschooling mom showed me a geography book she’s using called 180 Days Around the World that just asks questions for the student to search out. I rather like the idea.
    Part of the problem is, how do you evaluate if a student is engaged with the material? If you use essays it takes a lot of teacher time to go over them. It’s way faster and easier on the reporting system to have a series of blanks to be filled out. I wouldn’t be nearly as good an educator if I had to do it the “normal” way!

  3. Found your blog via Narrowboatwife and glad I have! As a home educating family I am looking forward to having a nose around all this great information…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s